HPPB Blog

Duty Of Care ~ Patient's Families

Does a doctor own a duty of care to members of a patient’s family where a diagnosis is in error?

 

 Untitled design - 2024-01-15T120721.521

We think a very significant judgement was handed down by the Supreme Court recently. It relates to whether a doctor owns a duty of care to members of a patient’s family where a diagnosis is in error.

 

We all know that the patient’s family suffer every bit as much as the patient in a variety of ways. Importantly, the Court distinguished the doctor patient relationship from other relationships in business or more generally (where a duty can exist for so called secondary victims). The Court found determined this duty does not extend to protecting their close family from the impact that negligent care or treatment could have. The Supreme Court found (at paragraph 138 of the judgment) “to impose such a responsibility on hospitals and doctors would go beyond what, in the current state of our society, is reasonably regarded as the nature and scope of their role”.

 

This may appear a dry subject, however, for those unfortunate enough to have to deal with this type of situation or for those more generally impacted by medical negligence issues we believe this is a sound decision.

 

Going forward, this has closed off a whole section of responsibility and will not be a cost driver for the future.

 

Read On

Fortune Favours The Brave -  When To Step In And Reporting To Insurers

This is the fourth part in a series of short articles designed to help medical practitioners manage...

Solicitors Refuse To Pay

Not Paid For Medico Legal Reports?

Aesthetic Insurance Video 4 ~ Change

Can you change insurer? What happens when you retire, do you still need cover?